На главнуюШоуПохожее видеоЕще от: Al Jazeera English

Inside Story - Are Afghanistan's Hazaras marginalised?

Оценок: 143 | Просмотров: 27944
The Hazara protesters demanded that the planned route for the 500 kV transmission line linking Turkmenistan with Kabul be changed to pass through two provinces with large Hazara populations, an option the government says would cost millions of dollars and delay the badly needed project by years. It says the current plan ensures that the two provinces of Bamyan and Wardak will get ample electricity even if the main transmission line does not pass through them directly. It has now been postponed while a government review is held. The Hazaras are an ethnic minority in Afghanistan who have long complained of discrimination. The protests are also shining a light on the Hazaras long-running grievances. So, are the Hazaras really discriminated against in Afghanistan? Or are they being manipulated by outside influences? Presenter: Folly Bah Thibault Guests: Habib Wardak - good governance and anti-corruption activist Rohullah Yakobi - associate fellow at the Human Security Centre; a Hazara who fled Afghanistan at the age of 12 Thomas Ruttig - co-director of the Afghanistan Analysts Network More from Inside Story on: YouTube - http://aje.io/insidestoryYT Facebook - https://facebook.com/AJInsideStory Twitter - https://twitter.com/AJInsideStory Website - http://aljazeera.com/insidestory/
Категория: Шоу



Html code for embedding videos on your blog
Текстовые комментарии (239)
monibrr mhs (5 дней назад)
WTF 10 they are 3 or %4 they are God shame which told to Afghanistan they will never happy if we give them all Afghanistan they son of iblis
Barmuda (2 месяца назад)
i think media should stop saying that who is how much in afghanistan 10 % or 20 % is a afghan made,its not like other countries where they count their population and say that much from that ethnicity since if they count that would be wrong since its everyone try to manipulate it so i request Al Jazeera not to use this so called percentage.... afghanistan is a country where everyone ethnicity is minorities .
A atA (5 месяцев назад)
And they did not think of planning and financial issues beforehand! Seriously!
ArSalaN (6 месяцев назад)
Major issues are that people demand personal needs more and specially benefiting their own ethnicity first. No one in Afghanistan are thinking of building the government first. Kabul the capital of Afghanistan is lacking electricity and government can’t process or improve without electricity in today’s world but other villagers are demanding electricity first and they expect government to protect them and bring stability. They don’t know that they themselves are the issues for instability in Afghanistan.
Ahmad Mauretano (6 месяцев назад)
Divide between good people and criminal people and not between ethnicity. I prefer a good hardworking hazara 1000 times more than a lazy criminal pasthun. And I prefer a good and hardworking pashtun 1000 times more than a lazy criminal hazara... When the good pasthun, hazara....let the criminals use them the criminals will lead us into new era of terror. Are 40 years of war not enough????????????? 😧😧😧
liska lizh (6 месяцев назад)
Many hazara stay here (Indonesia)
Khadim Hussain (7 месяцев назад)
We went hazaraistan
Pakhto- Hebrew (7 месяцев назад)
The reason Hazaras get killed is because they attack Pashtun nomads instead of fighting with Pashtuns as allies againt their commen enemy the Pakistani funded Taliban who hate shias such as Hazaras and also hate the Pashtun identity cuz we are Jews
afghan tiger safi (9 месяцев назад)
pukhtons are the real afghan. you dont like it? go to mangolia
Fereshte Akbarzada (6 месяцев назад)
Pashto is Jewish Go to Israel 🇮🇱
MonkGoneGamer (10 месяцев назад)
Its already been proved that Hazaras migrated from Central Asia long long before the Pashton immigration. Bamyan temples text culture exceeds Pashton culture by 100 of years. They are not Mongols but they were Central Asians .They were here before the invasion of Genghis khan.If you look at mountain people in India Tibet China Nepal Bhutan and Pakistan you will see how mountain people look or people from cold places. Even look in America Canada Antartica Alaska all people look somewhat Asian. These mountain people travelled all around the world from Siberia and Central Asia long long long time ago. These people were the first travellers and warriors who gave light to civilizations.
Raiz (9 месяцев назад)
Zoroaster Pakhtar disgusting! And now you're claiming hazara history as your own? Have you no shame? Of course bamiyan belongs to Hazaras. It is in "Hazarajat" afterall and multiple greek philosophers and travellers have documented hazaras in bamiyan 1000's of years ago. You truly have no pride in your people. Disgrace
MonkGoneGamer (10 месяцев назад)
Zoroaster Pakhtar Source or evidence?
Reza Haidary بیابد سوید (11 месяцев назад)
Fack azimi you are rasism
Reza Haidary بیابد سوید (11 месяцев назад)
Fack ashraf ghani
Dany Syed (11 месяцев назад)
Afghanistan belongs to the Pashtuns just like Canada belongs to the Aboriginals. Hazara’s came there with Ganghis khans army and settled . Hazaras belong to Mongolia
Noor Norderm (11 месяцев назад)
pashtuns have served mongols for decades, both during the khan of khans and during reign of Babur Shah in india/pakistan. thats why they proudly call themselves as khan
Afghan Lion (1 год назад)
These people are not innocent. Hazara's are taking money from Iran and serving Shia interests in the war in Syria. They have slaughtered thousands of Sunni's in the Middle East just to serve Iran's interest. They are traitors to Afghanistan. A decade ago, Hazara's weren't even considered citizens of Afghanistan rather mere immigrants.
Pakhto- Hebrew (7 месяцев назад)
Excuse Me ! Iran hates Pashtuns they dont want equality and u Hazaras r helping them to opress Pashthuns mongol savage
Noor Norderm (11 месяцев назад)
I think you have a sort of mind related illness, spreading hatred everywhere. People demonstrate for equality and electricity, you claim they got money from Iran. Even if that was true, well its good than that our neighbor is interested in equality in our country. Unlike Pashtoons getting money and weapon to destroy their country. What a shame.
KJ Vids (1 год назад)
Hazaristan will be Independent Free Hazaristan ✌️Fuck the Afghanistan land of terrorists
Pakhto- Hebrew (7 месяцев назад)
There is no such thig as Hazaristan. Afghanistan is a land of immgrants, Suck it up and deal with it Mongol immigrant
Turah Bacha (10 месяцев назад)
As a Pakistani Pashtun from Mardan khayber Pakhtunkhwa i would say go back to Mongolia. This is where u come from.
Afaaq Butt (1 год назад)
I support free hazaristan
Abdul Mosini (1 год назад)
You lie the hazara people right not you
nishant chandra (1 год назад)
hzaras are the future of Afghanistan.... I love them
Raiz (9 месяцев назад)
Zoroaster Pakhtar you're insane
Ahmad javedd (1 год назад)
Afghanistan will not be made untill pashtons live there because all of them suicide themselves for hurries
rick santos (1 год назад)
Are they discriminated against because they are Shia only or because they have Mongoloid features (when most of Afghanistan-Pak) is Caucasoid. I fact most Hazaras appear to be a mix of Caucasoid/Mongoloid, so I assume heavy mixing when on some time in history!
sakina hussaini (10 месяцев назад)
Both
Afaaq Butt (1 год назад)
rick santos They're discriminated because they look like east asians.
KJ Vids (1 год назад)
Zindabad Hazaristan
Lea Bouchard (1 год назад)
Most of these people look Asian as in Chinese, Koreas why are many Hazaras denying this? I had a friend from Afghanistan she told me she has Asian ancestry as in Hazaras blood put her family was ashamed of it for so long. Most of the Hazaras are denying they are Mongols well you look like them. That is why people are saying you have Asian blood. Asian as in the chinese are doing well and others perhaps you should come together with them?
Mr. Potato man (9 месяцев назад)
Zoroaster Pakhtar Hazaras are not pure Mongols not even pure East Asians. Hazaras are hybrid people of Mongoloid and Caucasoid race. 50% Mongoloid and 50% Caucasoid. Hazaras cluster closer with Uzbeks and Ughyrs in genetic tests than with Mongols or Pashtuns
Raiz (9 месяцев назад)
Zoroaster Pakhtar not true. I have read multiple articles on Hazaras genetic origin (ask and I shall provide the links). Depending on the individual, we have some variations in mongolic, turkic and central asian DNA. Hazaras are not pure mongols. Either you are lying through your teeth or you're deliberately spreading misinformation. Shame on you
Azeragi Turk (10 месяцев назад)
Zoroaster Pakhtar where is ur scientific proof man
Azeragi Turk (10 месяцев назад)
Zoroaster Pakhtar that's all lie not fact you got no proof about it.
Azeragi Turk (10 месяцев назад)
Zoroaster Pakhtar lol you are true ignorant.
KJ Vids (1 год назад)
We Must Stand against Afghan government who's Taliban. We Must fight again for Hazaristan. Independent Republic of Hazaristan. no more Islamic extremism
nickt1409 (2 года назад)
The partition of Afghanistan is the only viable way to prevent all that bloodshed and discrimination.Annexation of the Uzbek,Tajik and Turkmen areas to their motherlands in the north,a Hazara independent state in the central,a Balochi independent state in the south west and the rest half of the country to Pasthuns.Thats the only solution for the Yugoslavia of Central Asia.
Indigo Deco (2 года назад)
Long live Hazara's ❤️🇦🇫
Pakhto- Hebrew (7 месяцев назад)
Hazaras killed 20% of Pashtuns during the civil war with your bestfriend Massod. Hazaras ancestors the mongols killed 17+ million Pashtuns during the 1221 invasions of Afghanistan by Genghis Khan. Hazaras cut the breast of Pashtun women during the civil war, a distant relative of my cousin was a victim...she was raped and her breast cut by a Hazara from Hezbe Wahdat...Hazaras attack Pashtun nomads who need to travel freely around the country to survive...maybe you barabaric Mongol hazaras should return to the mountains of mongolia instead of killing Pashtuns who are the founding fathers of democracy (loya jirga)
Raiz (9 месяцев назад)
Zoroaster Pakhtar you pashtuns truly have no sense of honor, morality or common decency. The Hazara people have been 62% wiped out from their own country but you pashtuns somehow have to make everything about you. Selfish, shortsighted and idiotic. Afghanistan is a disgrace. You people do not belong in this country and should venture back to the arab deserts and herd your sheep. It's the only thing you're good for.
Hüseyin Şah Mirza (2 года назад)
If Hazara is from changez khan then why every Pashtuns last name is Khan it mean your the blood of changez khan There is no recode of Pashtuns in history of Afghanistan before 17th century
The art of Ball (2 месяца назад)
only the afghans from india have the khan behind their name. Non of the pashtuns from afghanistan are called khan. Lets do a dna test if you are a man, and lets see who is the real afghan
The art of Ball (2 месяца назад)
Azeragi Turk your mother is harami
Pakhto- Hebrew (7 месяцев назад)
Khan is derived from the Jewish Cohen. Pashtuns are Jews so they use the word Cohen which gradually developed into Khan...ur an idot
Azeragi Turk (11 месяцев назад)
Hüseyin Şah Mirza haha true brother these haramis pashtun are bunch of brainless people who hate changez khan while they use Khan as their name lol, but remember that we hazaras are old people of Khorasan, not these terrorists called pashtuns.
Hüseyin Şah Mirza (2 года назад)
We are in Afghanistan since 2000 years ago before Pashtuns are come from Israel and clam Afghanistan there country Hazara are ruler of Kushan empire who is the first Empire in Afghanistan history go to your land in Israel and stop killing Muslim you Pashtuns terrorists
Pakhto- Hebrew (7 месяцев назад)
Pashtuns are very proud Jews and Hazaras should be proud Mongols. Nobodyl truly belongs to Afghanistan, its a land of immigrants
RadioactivFallout (2 года назад)
Mongols are like jews they always complain everyware is bad if they aren't the ruling class
deb the RN (2 года назад)
great job of laying out the problem and explaining the multiply concerns of people. Thank You for covering this story.
Asfandyar Shafi (2 года назад)
Afghan Pashtun nationalists/racists are the biggest problem here.
Azeragi Turk (11 месяцев назад)
Pashtun Afghan stfu, a lot of hazaras joined Afghan Army, its the pashtuns who only joins the ISIS and Taliban to kill innocent people in Afghanistan.
Khan Saab (2 года назад)
+Pashtun Afghan in 2010 a survey from amnesty international shows that 67% of pushtuns youth are heading into drugs and the number is dropping from institutions. 99% opioids plant in Helmand province. In order to survive from drug addiction young pushtuns join Taliban. Got it kid? It's amnesty international words
Pashtun Afghan (2 года назад)
+3F he is a liar he not show proof where he get this information he is lying dirty shia just like all shia. We fallow pashtun wali and pashtun wali different from quran. these people not understand.
Pashtun Afghan (2 года назад)
Al Jazeera dirty Saudi Propaganda news. Death to Saudi Arabia death to Iran and Porkistan all Kuffar nations.
cybil israni (1 год назад)
Pashtun Afghan shut up afgandu
kasra20giv1 (2 года назад)
Pashtun Afghan lol, may you think that the only good muslims in afghanistan are pashtun talibans, of course they are very cultured people and are good representative of pashtuns.
Khan Saab (2 года назад)
Only you are Muslim lol go and blow yourself with your Taliban brothers
Yasir Temory (2 года назад)
Afghanistan government is terrorism they using infidels against hazaras they kill them because they are Hazaras???????????
Pashtun Afghan (2 года назад)
+Yasir Temory you dirty hazara refugee watan forosh dog of iran kuffar
Yasir Temory (2 года назад)
People of Hazara must be free from prosecution and discrimination
Raiz (9 месяцев назад)
Zoroaster Pakhtar go back to arab desert. Hazaras do have turkic and mongolic roots, but we have been in Hazarajat for longer than any other people. Bamiyan is proof of this. Pashtuns are arab nomads. Go back.
Yasir Temory (2 года назад)
I don't know what the white talking about
Yasir Temory (2 года назад)
The people in Afghanistan been prosecuted always just because they are Hazara the hazara people need justice in Afghanistan! !!
Khan Saab (2 года назад)
+Pashtun Afghan +Pashtun Afghan in 2010 a survey from amnesty international shows that 67% of pushtuns youth are heading into drugs and the number is dropping from institutions. 99% opioids plant in Helmand province. In order to survive from drug addiction young pushtuns join Taliban. Got it kid? It's amnesty international words
Micheal Stevenson (2 года назад)
Aren't Hazara Mongolians? so why don't they go back to Mongolia there is no war there
Ali Baba (2 года назад)
+3F lol! You sound so dumb and full of it. I am not East Asian . Actually a hodge podge of european mixture but i call myself Canadian and trust me, white folks don't think of you as part of the family. LMAO. Delusional, much? Look at the way your kind is being received in Europe and America? If anything, east asians are more welcome and appreciated than brown Muslims in the west.
Ali Baba (2 года назад)
+3F please! Buddhism is not an offshoot of Zoroastrianism. If anything, it bears slight resemblance to Hinduism but only slightly. Buddhism originated in modern day Nepal.
Mr. Potato man (2 года назад)
Omg! Those Afghan officials sounded like retards. They can't even talk properly.
KJ Vids (11 месяцев назад)
So True Bro!!!
Ali Yawar (2 года назад)
tutup is the full rights of bamiyan's and hazara people's. how many project of powers has made in pashtun provinces? uncountable millions of dollar have spent in pashtun provinces what is, you after some months bombed and destroyed and this projecr is haazara's right full stop.
gigi garzuly (2 года назад)
hazaras have always been a persecuted minority. reading up on history will suffice to confirm that. on another note, why, oh why, is the world´s media legitimizing daesh by calling them isis,isil etc. daesh is not a state as the other sinonyms suggest! why credit that bunch of deranged murderers with "a state" it doesn´t have- if daesh hates being called daesh, why not use daesh?
Khal Drogo (2 года назад)
Hazaras are the shittiest, they take refugee status in Pakistan whilst supporting the taliban. They get free visa passes to go to germany, sweden, uk, and Canada and then they cry wolf. What a shame. While millions of pashtuns have stayed to defend their lands till the end. Absolutely disgusting.
KJ Vids (11 месяцев назад)
Because Your Pashtuns terrorists and that's why we are leaving.
Noor Norderm (11 месяцев назад)
u have clearly had a lot of "history" lessons.
Ghulam Mohammad Shujaee (1 год назад)
Khal Drogo you don't know what is going on in Afghanistan! it is better not to judge easily! you have to be Hazara to feel the pain with your own body!
Kotten Bengt (1 год назад)
Khal Drogo stfu you stupid idiot
Azra (1 год назад)
Where do you get those sources from that Hazaras support Taliban? Hazaras have been oppressed and genocide by Taliban ( Pashtuns). I don't understand how can someone support who kills your people? I think you are one those have no idea about Hazaras in Afghanistan. Please read or find someone who knows about Hazaras and don't talk rubbish please.
raceguy Benz (2 года назад)
other minority people in Afghanistan never have been killed and diskriminated as much as hazaras in Afhanistans history. It is enought to check over the road map in Afghanistan u will see that in the center of Afghanistan, It is as an irland there no roads pass, no development-programs of goverment reach, Still hazaras youngers fight as same sida as others against afghanistans enemies and do their duty as best as other groups in Afghaistan but in differenence they dont have the same rights as others.
Ghulam Mohammad Shujaee (1 год назад)
Long live all the tribes in Afghanistan. the Afghan government will pay for what what they do now , do discriminations and genocide especially to Hazara.we will stand against this discriminations with all our forces because we want a peaceful Afghanistan for all not only for Hazara.
raceguy Benz (2 года назад)
I dont care about what it done during the Kabul war, if u want to analyze, u see the Hekmatyar is destoryer of whole of Kabul and Ahmad shah massud did genocide in Afshar, a district of Kabul. I can tell you, Taliban did not kill 11000 pashtuns or tajiks or uzbaks in mazar, but they killed civil hazaras there and Taliban did not done genocide in Panjshir, kabul or qandahar, they did it in Bamyan, Yekawlang and jabreil (a hazara district i Herat). If a pashtun, uzbak or tajik travel to herat via qandahar he has no risk to be killed but many hazaras have been killed in Baqran, nawzad, moqur, hemland during their jourey via south Afghanistan, If u see the map of Afghanistan u see an iland in central of afghanistan there no roas goes, nothing of goverment developments projects take places. I ask u why hazaras in Oruzgan got and try to get tazkira in name of Tajik, why beacause they r tired of suffering and diskriminaring of goverment and other groups, I am not hazara but I have travelled to those places and saw them by my eyes.
Jaghori Zeba (2 года назад)
the whole world 🌍 now understands and fully know whose the talibans daesh etc and whose killing inner Afghans under ethnicity reasons such as Hazaras... Hazaras has always been the hardworking skilled educated and advanced ethnicity in Afghanistan... they would never blow themselves up by killing Tajiks Uzbeks or pashtons.....
Hamid Panjsheri (2 года назад)
The guy from Kabul is saying bullshit, the majority of Ghazni populations are Hazaras and tajiks are the minority
Afghan Lion (1 год назад)
Ghazni is mostly Pashtun.
sam G (2 года назад)
Time to Wikipedia his and your claim.
hamid954 (2 года назад)
+Hamid Panjsheri He was talking about Ghazni province not city.
Hamid Panjsheri (2 года назад)
every government has had discriminated policy towards the Hazaras and history knows that. Pashtuns has always been puppets of Pakistan and the west. Pashtuns are fighting side by side with ISIS in syria against the whole world
Khan Saab (2 года назад)
+Pashtun Afghan +Pashtun Afghan in 2010 a survey from amnesty international shows that 67% of pushtuns youth are heading into drugs and the number is dropping from institutions. 99% opioids plant in Helmand province. In order to survive from drug addiction young pushtuns join Taliban. Got it kid? It's amnesty international words
Pashtun Afghan (2 года назад)
+Hamid Panjsheri dirty panjsheri slave of Iran. Dirty dogs like you are dying in Syria because ayatollah tell you to die. Afghan Army 67 per cent Pashtun. you refugee dog watan forosh. Why they call pansheri robbers and steallers because you dogs steal everything and sell to iran and porkistan.
Inherent Emperor (2 года назад)
Why turkmen, tajik, uzbek aren't protesting.? Hahaa Hypocrite hazarah
KJ Vids (11 месяцев назад)
They are all did like Tajiks in 1990s so is Uzbek and Turkmens
Mustafa Shujaie (2 года назад)
+Khal Drogo I have no idea what are you talking about? India? My lords? I do not blame you, You watched game of thrones a lot and got confused
Khal Drogo (2 года назад)
+Mustafa Shujaie get out of kabul you hazara rat, you belong in india where your lords live.
Hamid Panjsheri (2 года назад)
Hazaras are the most civilised, peaceful and education lovers of Afghanistan. during the last fourteen years Hazaras haven't harmed a single human being. Hazara brothers the future belongs to you and your Tajiks brothers will always stand side by side with you to fight discrimination and puppets of Pakistan.
Omeed RMA AFG (15 дней назад)
+TYBALT.videos {[5]} Afghanistan=land of the pashtuns stupid!
ArfaArmy (1 год назад)
Pashtun Afghan Choub Ko Ahmack, thou ra muckshoum
Batoor Safi (1 год назад)
Love from Pashtun
Inherent Emperor (2 года назад)
Stupid hazara they are just manipulated by irani.. Simple..
Kotten Bengt (1 год назад)
Inherent Emperor lol you're a idiot
Inherent Emperor (2 года назад)
Hazara are. not from. Afghanistan simple as that.
Zia Yawari (5 месяцев назад)
Inherent Emperor and you're not from your dad simple as this
SATIZ PULAMI (1 год назад)
Pashtun Afghan so Mongolians can't live in Afghanistan? I am from Nepal can you explain me so I can make my mind towards pasthun
ganbat e (1 год назад)
Ablaikhan Bennett rouran state is a state of mongols
Mr. Potato man (2 года назад)
+Inherent Emperor you call yourself as "father of history" and yet you don't know the origins behind the title "Khan"? Haha, what a joke!

Хотите оставить комментарий?

Присоединитесь к YouTube, или войдите, если вы уже зарегистрированы.